At the Other Keyboard HAS MOVED

Share this post

User's avatar
At the Other Keyboard HAS MOVED
On the substitution problem and having correct opinions

On the substitution problem and having correct opinions

Sharon's Weekly Head Dump

Sharon Su — MOVED's avatar
Sharon Su — MOVED
Jan 14, 2023
∙ Paid
Share

Happy 2023, everyone! Hope you all had a lovely, restful holiday season and start to the new year.

Today’s newsletter will be in a slightly different format than usual since I’ve stored up updates and longer-form thoughts over the past couple of weeks.

Some news

After two months of Secret Behind the Scenes Workings, I can finally announce that I am a 2023 Fellow with Turn the Spotlight!

I am still flummoxed to find myself named as one of seven “creators and change-makers” in classical music; as part of this year’s fellowship, I’ll be working on a large-scale project with the help of my mentor, the wonderful Kathleen Kelly.

Full disclosure that I actually have no idea what my project will be yet—I’m kind of hoping that some marvelous idea will just hit me out of the blue one day. The year is still young, right?

Original manuscript of Fanny Mendelssohn Hensel’s Piano Sonata in G Minor.

In other news, we’re nearing the finish line on the Fanny Mendelssohn Hensel piano concerto I’d previously announced; the premiere is scheduled for March 9 in Boston, Massachusetts. I’ll have more information later, but for now, I’ll just be furiously practicing some freshly written music and wondering what possessed me to have this idea in the first place.

Twitter avatar for @doodlyroses
🎹 sharon su 🎹 @doodlyroses
Me in 2022 agreeing to a thing: oh sure I can absolutely learn a new concerto by March 9 that’s like five decades from now Me 11 days into 2023: wait March 9 is less than two months from now………how did that happen
2:07 AM ∙ Jan 12, 2023

A common problem

This is purely anecdata, but I’ve noticed lately that Fanny Mendelssohn seems to be getting more airtime; when I was talking to the music director and conductor of one symphony, he mentioned that they’d performed Fanny’s Overture in a recent season. Next week Jeremy Denk and the Takács Quartet will be performing Fanny’s String Quintet here in LA, and this weekend the Los Angeles Chamber Orchestra was scheduled to perform Fanny’s Overture. (I’d originally called LACO out for using a portrait of a completely different woman to represent Fanny Mendelssohn Hensel on their program page.)

Twitter avatar for @doodlyroses
🎹 sharon su 🎹 @doodlyroses
pssssst @LACOtweets! this portrait on your concert page is not Fanny Mendelssohn (Hensel), Felix's older sister and artistic partner; it's Cécile Mendelssohn, Felix's wife laco.org/events/sheku-h…
Portion of a screenshot from a concert page for the Los Angeles Chamber Orchestra; a column shows a portrait of a woman identified as Fanny Mendelssohn (Hensel), to promote a performance of her Overture in C Major. However, the portrait is not actually of Fanny Mendelssohn Hensel, and is in reality a portrait of Cécile Mendelssohn, Felix Mendelssohn's wife.
5:33 PM ∙ Sep 16, 2022
61Likes5Retweets

I say “LACO was scheduled” because…things happened. I got an email this week from LACO with the subject line “Change of Plans” (bolding is mine):

Unfortunately, our Music Director Jaime Martín has tested positive for COVID-19 and is unable to travel to Los Angeles to conduct this weekend’s concerts. In his stead, we’re thrilled to announce Lina González-Granados has agreed to lead LACO in this exciting program of Classical-era gems. 

One of the most exciting young conductors working today, Lina was recently appointed Resident Conductor of the LA Opera. She is also a Solti Conducting Apprentice at the Chicago Symphony, a Sphinx Medal of Excellence winner, and has guest conducted the Philadelphia Orchestra, Seattle Symphony, the Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra, Opera Philadelphia, and many others. Also, please note that the program will now begin with Felix Mendelssohn’s Hebrides. The rest of the program will be performed as published.

In short, because of a last minute conductor swap, the Fanny Mendelssohn Hensel piece has been replaced with a standard piece by Felix Mendelssohn.

Before I go on: this was, imho, absolutely the right call. I am not mad at the decision, and I have no desire to call anyone out over it. It would have been incredibly unfair to everyone involved to have a last-minute substitute conductor perform a piece she’s not familiar with, and I am a strong proponent of the idea that we need strong showings of underrepresented works, for reasons I went into in this post:

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to At the Other Keyboard HAS MOVED to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Sharon Su
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share